States of Deliberation - 21st June 2023

View this meeting's information page on gov.gg

Deferred Propositions

Proposition Reference Title Proposition Migrated To
P.2023/38 Amendment 4 - St Pier/Bury 6. Education Law Review To delete “and” at the end of proposition 32 b) and to replace the full stop at the end of propos...
P.2023/38 Amendment 5 - St Pier/Soulsby 6. Education Law Review To add before the semi-colon in proposition 26 i) “and provisions for term limits for Governors”...
P.2023/38 Amendment 9 - Trott/Fairclough 6. Education Law Review See URL for the full text of the Amendment
P.2023/38 Amendment 10 - St. Pier/Trott 6. Education Law Review In proposition 26b), immediately before the semi-colon, insert:- “and no Governor shall be entit...
P.2023/38 Amendment 14 - Kazantseva-Miller/Falla 6. Education Law Review In proposition 3, to delete “free”.
P.2023/38 Amendment 16 - Dudley-Owen/Haskins 6. Education Law Review In Proposition 42 delete the square brackets and the words in them
P.2023/38 Amendment 17 - Matthews/Gollop 6. Education Law Review To insert the following at the end of proposition 25: ‘and that the management of admission will ...
P.2023/38 Amendment 18 - Gollop/Matthews 6. Education Law Review For Proposition 26, substitute the following proposition:- “To agree that, in relation to the go...
P.2023/38 All Propositions as amended 6. Education Law Review See attached URL for link to the Original Propositions As amended by the following amendments: 11
P.2023/38 Proposition 1. 6. Education Law Review 1. To agree that the principles and objectives of the education law should be as described in sec...
P.2023/38 Proposition 1A (As inserted by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 1A To agree that, for the purposes of the Education Law, an ‘Accredited Independent School’ sha...
P.2023/38 Proposition 2. 6. Education Law Review 2. To agree that there shall be a universal entitlement to education as set out in paragraph 6.2 ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 3. 6. Education Law Review 3. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture shall ensure the availability of an...
P.2023/38 Proposition 4. 6. Education Law Review 4. To agree that ‘Compulsory Education Age’ will be from the beginning of the academic year in wh...
P.2023/38 Proposition 5. 6. Education Law Review 5. To agree the principle of an ‘Education Participation Age’, as set out in paragraph 6.16.
P.2023/38 Proposition 6. 6. Education Law Review 6. To agree that when the law comes into force, the upper and lower limits of ‘Education Particip...
P.2023/38 Proposition 7. 6. Education Law Review 7. To agree that when the law comes into force the ‘Preschool Funding Entitlement’, will be that ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 8. 6. Education Law Review 8. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture should ensure sufficient quality-as...
P.2023/38 Proposition 9. 6. Education Law Review 9. To agree that designated officers shall be responsible for the educational outcomes of Childre...
P.2023/38 Proposition 10. 6. Education Law Review 10. To note that in accordance with recommendation 9 of the Guernsey and Alderney SEND review 202...
P.2023/38 Proposition 11. 6. Education Law Review 11. To agree that in relation to Additional Learning Needs: a) the Committee for Education, Sport...
P.2023/38 Proposition 12. 6. Education Law Review 12. To agree that the curriculum specified by the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture should...
P.2023/38 Proposition 13. 6. Education Law Review 13. To agree that States-maintained schools shall interpret the curriculum and deliver education ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 16. 6. Education Law Review 16. To agree that in States-maintained schools where collective worship takes place it is underta...
P.2023/38 Proposition 17 (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 17. To agree that, in relation to inspection: a) all States-maintained schools, Voluntary school...
P.2023/38 Proposition 18. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 18. To agree that in relation to exclusions: a) the permanent exclusion from States-maintained an...
P.2023/38 Proposition 19. (as amended by Amdt 7) 6. Education Law Review 19. To agree that in relation to attendance: a) all schools shall be required to hold and maintai...
P.2023/38 Proposition 20. 6. Education Law Review 20. To agree that there should be flexibility to enable the Committee for Education, Sport & Cult...
P.2023/38 Proposition 21. 6. Education Law Review 21. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture may operate a transport policy to ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 22. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 22. To agree that any transport policy operated by the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture m...
P.2023/38 Proposition 23. 6. Education Law Review 23. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture shall be required to identify chil...
P.2023/38 Proposition 23A (as inserted by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 23A To direct the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture to agree a process, to be set by non-...
P.2023/38 Proposition 24. (as amended by Amdts 1 & 3) 6. Education Law Review 24. To agree that in relation to home education: a) the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture...
P.2023/38 Proposition 25. 6. Education Law Review 25. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture will manage admissions to States-m...
P.2023/38 Proposition 26 (amended by Amdt 11 then subsequently replaced in full by Amdt 12) 6. Education Law Review 26. To direct the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture to return to the States as soon as pra...
P.2023/38 Proposition 27. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 27. To agree that appointment to the role of the Director of Education shall be made by the Polic...
P.2023/38 Proposition 28. 6. Education Law Review 28. To agree that there will be a statutory right of appeal against decisions taken by or on beha...
P.2023/38 Proposition 29. 6. Education Law Review 29. To agree that in relation to voluntary schools that: a) only those voluntary schools in place...
P.2023/38 Proposition 30. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 30. To agree that in relation to independent schools: a) proprietors (being the persons or body...
P.2023/38 Proposition 30A. (as inserted by Amdt 6) 6. Education Law Review 30A To agree that the constitution, staffing, organisation and curriculum of the Independent sch...
P.2023/38 Proposition 31. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 31. To agree that in relation to the responsibilities to safeguard and promote the welfare and we...
P.2023/38 Proposition 32. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 32. To agree that in relation to the health and wellbeing of learners: a) the Committee for Educa...
P.2023/38 Proposition 33. 6. Education Law Review 33. To agree that corporal punishment should be prohibited in all schools, registered pre-school ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 34. 6. Education Law Review 34. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture may prescribe the standards to be ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 35. 6. Education Law Review 35. To agree that there should be flexibility to enable the expansion of school meal provision, i...
P.2023/38 Proposition 36. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 36. To agree that the sharing of data shall be required, as necessary, to support (i) effective s...
P.2023/38 Proposition 36A (as inserted by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 36A To direct the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture to consult on and agree with all Indep...
P.2023/38 Proposition 37. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 37. To agree that the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture, must publish an annual report in ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 38. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 38. To agree that parents/carers of learners in States-maintained and Voluntary schools of compul...
P.2023/38 Proposition 39. 6. Education Law Review 39. To agree that all registered education settings for learners of or above compulsory education...
P.2023/38 Proposition 40. 6. Education Law Review 40. To agree that in all registered education settings for learners of or above compulsory educat...
P.2023/38 Proposition 40A (as inserted by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 40A To agree that teachers and lecturers who are already employed in any States-maintained, Volun...
P.2023/38 Proposition 41. (as amended by Amdt 8) 6. Education Law Review 41. To direct that the Law shall: a) carry forward those provisions of The Education (Guernsey)...
P.2023/38 Proposition 41A (as inserted by Amdt 13 and then amended by Amdt 15) 6. Education Law Review 41A. To direct the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture to consult with key stakeholders: in ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 42. 6. Education Law Review 42. To direct the Law Officers to prepare such legislation as may be necessary to give effect to ...
P.2023/38 Proposition 43. 6. Education Law Review 43. To direct the Committee for Education, Sport & Culture to consult with the States of Alderney...
P.2023/38 Proposition 44. 6. Education Law Review 44. To direct that any consequential amendments to the mandate or operational functions of the Co...
P.2023/32 7. Schedule for future States' business The States are asked to decide:- Whether, after consideration of the attached Schedule for Futur...

Finished Propositions

Proposition Reference Voted Title Overall Result Pour Contre Ne vote pas Did not vote Absent Total
P.2023/33 Amendment 1 HMP/HMC 21/06/2023 10:46 1. The Prevention of Discrimination (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Guernsey) Ordinance, 2023 Pour 36 0 0 1 3 40
P.2023/33 As amended by Amendment 1 21/06/2023 10:48 1. The Prevention of Discrimination (Miscellaneous Amendments) (Guernsey) Ordinance, 2023 Pour 36 0 0 1 3 40
P.2023/34 21/06/2023 10:58 2. The Criminal Justice (Proceeds of Crime and Drug Trafficking) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023 Pour 36 0 0 1 3 40
P.2023/35 21/06/2023 11:20 3.The Guernsey Financial Services Commission (Transfer of Functions) (Fees) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Ordinance, 2023 Pour 31 4 2 0 3 40
P.2023/36 All Propositions 21/06/2023 11:23 4. Legislation on International Co-operation Pour 35 0 0 2 3 40
P.2023/37 All Propositions 21/06/2023 11:51 5. Interim Uprating of Income Support Rates Pour 32 3 2 0 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 11-Dudley Owen/Haskins 21/06/2023 12:25 6. Education Law Review Pour 35 0 0 2 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 1) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:18 6. Education Law Review Pour 25 9 2 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 2a) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:19 6. Education Law Review Pour 18 16 2 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 3) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:21 6. Education Law Review Pour 21 14 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 4) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:22 6. Education Law Review Pour 23 12 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 5) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:23 6. Education Law Review Pour 23 12 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 6) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:25 6. Education Law Review Pour 31 3 2 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 7) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:26 6. Education Law Review Pour 27 8 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 8) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:27 6. Education Law Review Pour 18 16 2 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 9) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:28 6. Education Law Review Pour 24 11 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 10) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:29 6. Education Law Review Pour 24 11 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 11a) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:31 6. Education Law Review Pour 19 16 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 12) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:32 6. Education Law Review Pour 21 14 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 13) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:33 6. Education Law Review Pour 22 13 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 14) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:34 6. Education Law Review Pour 23 12 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 15) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:36 6. Education Law Review Pour 23 12 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 16) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:37 6. Education Law Review Pour 22 13 1 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 8 (Proposition 17) - Trott/Fairclough 22/06/2023 10:38 6. Education Law Review Pour 19 12 5 0 4 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 1 - Burford/Oliver 22/06/2023 12:11 6. Education Law Review Pour 27 9 0 1 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 2 - Burford/Oliver 22/06/2023 12:27 6. Education Law Review Pour 28 8 0 1 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 3 - Burford/Oliver 22/06/2023 14:42 6. Education Law Review Pour 26 7 1 3 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 6 - Soulsby/Le Tocq 22/06/2023 15:22 6. Education Law Review Pour 32 4 1 0 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 13 - Murray/Ferbrache 22/06/2023 16:05 6. Education Law Review Pour 31 5 1 0 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 12- Roffey/Soulsby 22/06/2023 17:49 6. Education Law Review Pour 22 14 0 1 3 40
23/06/2023 09:35 To adjourn for one hour Pour 19 13 1 0 7 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 15 - Roffey/Burford 23/06/2023 10:50 6. Education Law Review Pour 22 14 1 0 3 40
P.2023/38 Amendment 7 - Matthews/de Lisle 23/06/2023 11:44 6. Education Law Review Pour 25 11 1 0 3 40
23/06/2023 12:30 Rule 26(1) Motion (* P.2023/38 Motion to Withdraw - Dudley-Owen/Haskins ) Pour 20 15 1 1 3 40
P.2023/38 Motion to Withdraw - Dudley-Owen/Haskins 23/06/2023 12:39 6. Education Law Review Pour 27 9 0 1 3 40
P.2023/32 Amendment 1 - de Sausmarez/Cameron 23/06/2023 12:44 7. Schedule for future States' business Pour 18 15 2 2 3 40
P.2023/32 All Propositions (as amended by Amdt 1) 23/06/2023 12:45 7. Schedule for future States' business Pour 30 2 3 2 3 40